‘Kneeding’ a break: First evidence ACL injuries an overuse failure

Repetitive knee stress and failure to accommodate sufficient rest between periods of strenuous exercise may be key factors behind the rapid rise in anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries in world sport, a new international study has found.

Former Dallas Texans player Christina Gordon (wearing brace) gave up club soccer after breaking her femur and tearing the ACL in both knees over a three-year span with the Texans. Dallas Morning News

Leigh Dawson, Monash University 24 July 2019

Repetitive knee stress and lack of rest are major causes of ACL failure, according to new research.

The peak age for ACL failures is 14. People in mid-20s suffering from osteoarthritis and other chronic health conditions.

Australia has the highest reported rates of ACL injuries and reconstructions per capita in the world.

Repetitive knee stress and a lack of rest are major causes of ACL failure according to new research by the University of Michigan and Monash University.

But this world-first research, published in the American Journal of Sports Medicine, has found that a series of submaximal forces can indeed cause damage to accrue in the ACL, in a process called low-cycle material fatigue, and that same damage is found in ACLs which have failed.

While it is already well recognised that a single supramaximal force can cause ACL failure, it has been assumed that sub-maximal forces could not cause ACL failure.

The problem of ACL injuries is described by researchers as a ‘ticking time bomb’ because of the number of these injuries and the degeneration in the knee that they can cause. This study provides an important new mechanism beyond the common view that ACL failures occur due to a single sudden or forceful movement and/or a lack of neuromuscular training.

Above all, researchers have shown that competitive sporting environments are producing generations of athletes that risk developing knee osteoarthritis no matter how they are treated.

Academics from the University of Michigan and Monash University have argued that material fatigue is behind the steep rise in ‘non-contact’ ACL injuries. Nearly three-quarters of ACL injuries are ‘non-contact’ failures, even in contact sports like Australian Rules Football and the American National Football League (NFL).

“ACL injuries are the number one cause of time spent away from NFL practice and play, with recovery periods up to 12 months long,” said lead researcher and orthopaedic surgeon, Dr Edward Wojtys, who has been studying this issue for more than 30 years.

“Incredibly, we’re seeing that the peak age for ACL failures is 14. This can lead to people in the mid-20s suffering from osteoarthritis and other chronic health conditions later in life, such as obesity and cardiovascular disease. Female athletes are at most risk.”

Led by Dr Edward Wojtys and biomechanical engineer Professor James Ashton-Miller, both from the University of Michigan, the team tested one healthy knee from each of seven adult cadavers in a controlled laboratory study using a purpose-built machine, which took three years to develop.

Each knee was subjected to repetitive pivot landings loaded under four-times body weight – approximately the weight under which someone jumps and lands – which twisted the knee to cause ACL failure within 100 landings.

What they couldn’t see was what was happening to the ACL itself inside the knee, especially near the thigh bone where the team knew most ACLs fail.

Professor Mark Banaszak Holl, Head of Chemical Engineering at Monash University, joined this project in order to answer that question – along with two PhD students Jinhee Kim and Junjie Chen.

Using atomic force microscopy to characterise the ACL collagen at the nanometre scale, or one billionth of a metre, Professor Banaszak Holl and his team were able to identify a consistent unravelling of the molecular structure of the ACL’s collagen in the injured cadaver knees.

Professor Banaszak Holl said the results of this latest research throw into serious doubt the argument that most ACL injuries are caused by single force events. This could lead to different ways of managing athletes of all ages and levels.

“What we found from the tested cadaver knees was chemical and structural evidence of micro-damage of the ACL femoral enthesis, which is where the ligament attaches to the thigh bone and where the ACL typically tears,” he said.

“These results were consistent with ACLs removed from patients undergoing knee reconstructions.

“The new hope is that a change in athlete training and preparation could then limit the number of risky submaximal loading cycles. Allowing sufficient time for soft tissue recovery during or between training bouts could prevent the accumulation of ACL micro-damage and eventual failure.

“Now that we know the nature of the problem and the structural changes occurring, we can look for non-invasive ways of determining who is predisposed to injuring their ACL.”

ACL injuries are a global trend with more than two million people having surgery to repair their torn ligaments each year. Australia currently has the highest reported rates of ACL injuries and reconstructions per capita in the world.

But this isn’t just happening at the elite level. According to a study published last year in the Medical Journal of Australia, the number of young Australians requiring knee reconstructions in the previous 15 years has jumped by 70%. The greatest increase was in children under 14, with some as young as eight going in for surgery.

“We have to ask ourselves the question; is more always better?” Professor Ashton-Miller said.

“Until we have more answers, it’s not worth pushing our bodies and ligaments to the extreme because of the potential long-term damage it can cause. There are limits to what the human body can tolerate. Being more selective about the training that is done is clearly warranted.

“Fewer repetitions known to significantly stress the ACL will ultimately lead to fewer injuries. This should be the main focus of sporting clubs and athletes of all ages and levels of professionalism.”

Source Monash University
via EurekAlert! AAAS

An Anterior Cruciate Ligament Failure Mechanism, Chen J, Kim J, Shao W, Schlecht SH, Baek SY, Jones AK, Ahn T, Ashton-Miller JA, Banaszak Holl MM, Wojtys EM. Am J Sports Med. 2019 Jul;47(9):2067-2076. doi: 10.1177/0363546519854450.
  Further reading
Multiplanar Loading of the Knee and Its Influence on Anterior Cruciate Ligament and Medial Collateral Ligament Strain During Simulated Landings and Noncontact Tears, Bates NA, Schilaty ND, Nagelli CV, Krych AJ, Hewett TE. Am J Sports Med. 2019 Jul;47(8):1844-1853. doi: 10.1177/0363546519850165. Epub 2019 May 31.

Strain Response of the Anterior Cruciate Ligament to Uniplanar and Multiplanar Loads During Simulated Landings: Implications for Injury Mechanism, Kiapour AM, Demetropoulos CK, Kiapour A, Quatman CE, Wordeman SC, Goel VK, Hewett TE. Am J Sports Med. 2016 Aug;44(8):2087-96. doi: 10.1177/0363546516640499. Epub 2016 Apr 13.

Relative strain in the anterior cruciate ligament and medial collateral ligament during simulated jump landing and sidestep cutting tasks: implications for injury risk, Bates NA, Nesbitt RJ, Shearn JT, Myer GD, Hewett TE. Am J Sports Med. 2015 Sep;43(9):2259-69. doi: 10.1177/0363546515589165. Epub 2015 Jul 6. Full text

Risk of anterior cruciate ligament fatigue failure is increased by limited internal femoral rotation during in vitro repeated pivot landings, Beaulieu ML, Wojtys EM, Ashton-Miller JA. Am J Sports Med. 2015 Sep;43(9):2233-41. doi: 10.1177/0363546515589164. Epub 2015 Jun 29. Full text

Anterior cruciate ligament fatigue failures in knees subjected to repeated simulated pivot landings, Lipps DB, Wojtys EM, Ashton-Miller JA, Am J Sports Med. 2013 May;41(5):1058-66. doi: 10.1177/0363546513477836. Epub 2013 Mar 4. Full text

Clinically relevant injury patterns after an anterior cruciate ligament injury provide insight into injury mechanisms, Levine JW, Kiapour AM, Quatman CE, Wordeman SC, Goel VK, Hewett TE, Demetropoulos CK. Am J Sports Med. 2013 Feb;41(2):385-95. doi: 10.1177/0363546512465167. Epub 2012 Nov 9. Full text

Preferential loading of the ACL compared with the MCL during landing: a novel in sim approach yields the multiplanar mechanism of dynamic valgus during ACL injuries, Quatman CE, Kiapour AM, Demetropoulos CK, Kiapour A, Wordeman SC, Levine JW, Goel VK, Hewett TE. Am J Sports Med. 2014 Jan;42(1):177-86. doi: 10.1177/0363546513506558. Epub 2013 Oct 11. Full text

Call 403-240-9100