Canadian patients should have online access to their medical records, some doctors say
‘You’re part of the care,’ says daughter who monitors her mom’s cancer treatment online.
With files from Christine Birak and Marcy Cuttler, CBC News August 03, 2018
When Amelda Wright, 78, gets a new test as part of her cancer care, her daughter logs into her patient record from home so she can tell her the results.
“You do feel more in control. You’re part of the care,” Yvonne Wright said.
|Access is empowering, doctor says|
Provincial and territorial governments, which have jurisdiction over health care for most Canadians, “should mandate patient portals of access to electronic medical records, as such a commitment to health information transparency would herald a new era in patient empowerment,” wrote family physician Dr. Iris Gorfinkel and emergency physician Dr. Joel Lexchin.
“Records accessible to patients need not be all inclusive, but should, at a minimum, include the primary care physician’s cumulative patient profile,” including a summary of “a patient’s social, family, medical and surgical history; substance use; current medications; previous drug intolerances; and drug allergies.”
Consultation notes from specialists, radiology and lab reports should also be available, they wrote.
That kind of empowerment “changes the nature of the dialogue with physicians” and help people stay on top of their own health care, Gorfinkel told CBC News.
|Patients already entitled to see records|
The data available to patients in most existing portals — including the one she provides to her own patients — is currently quite “limited” and just a starting point, she said.
Ultimately, Gorfinkel said, patients should be able to access the same information their primary care provider would have, finding answers to questions such as, “When did I last have my mammogram? OK, here’s my mammogram results. What does my bone density show? You know, when was my last colonoscopy? The standard family physician things. What vaccinations have I had?
“I now have full access to it 24/7,” she said. “That’s the idea. To try to bring that to patients.”
Under Canadian law, patients are already entitled to see their records and charts, whether they are paper or electronic. But the process of getting access is generally cumbersome, said Kerry Bowman, a bioethicist at the University of Toronto.
|‘The right way to go’|
“The information may belong to the patient but the physical chart itself, including its software and its components, is in the ownership of the hospital or the health-care facility,” he said. “So what happens is you get a bit of a bureaucratic structure in which you have to do paperwork and wait.”
Patient portals “will absolutely help” address that problem, he said.
“From an ethical point of view, it’s the right way to go. From a transparency point of view, it’s the right way to go.”
But Bowman also sees serious risks and problems that need to be addressed.
“The first thing I would worry about is the security of the information and confidentiality,” he said.
“A portal is just what it sounds to be — it’s an opening in the system. And with that opening comes increased risk for unauthorized entry of some kind.”
|Jargon, anxious patients among challenges|
Another challenge, he said, is making sure patients understand what they’re reading — especially given the extensive jargon used in the medical world.
“It may not have to be written in layman’s terms, but it’s going to have to be written a lot more clearly than it is now, there’s no question about that.”
Bowman said another issue that will arise is how patients handle the information they access.
“It may put a lot of stress [on patients],” he said. “If you take the example of a patient getting… their final results related to, you know, a biopsy, let’s imagine, on a Friday night. What is that patient, what is she supposed to do with that information? What are her options?”Informed discussion more likely
stress is a “potential downside,” Gorfinkel said, but the results “are what they are,” regardless of how people get them. Being armed with that information in advance could also prompt patients to do some research and prepare for an informed conversation with their doctor, she added.”By the time you come speak to your family physician about it, you’re going to be knowledgeable,” she said. “[Patients are] able to say: Wait a second. I had this result… aren’t we going to do something about it?”
Knowing that patients will see their records will also hold physicians accountable for accurate documentation, she said.
“Doctors will be more cautious about what they write, how they write… If I get something wrong when I’m writing details about a patient, I would want to know where I’m wrong. Correct me. There’s literally thousands of facts on any given chart. So if I don’t have my facts right, that could potentially negatively impact patient care.”
Both Gorfinkel and Bowman acknowledge that not all patients will embrace the idea of accessing their medical information — online or otherwise.
“Individual reaction will be quite different. You’re going to have patients that say: I wouldn’t open that portal for anything… It’s going to upset me, I’m not going to understand it,” Bowman said. “You’re going to have other very anxious people who are going to read it constantly… and a lot of people will be somewhere in between.”
But even patients who don’t want to look at their information will benefit from having it all collected electronically in one place, Gorfinkel said.
In an emergency department, for example, patients often can’t remember all the medication they are on — or provide their entire medical history.
“If portals to primary-care charts were universal, then patients… could simply say: My doctor has a patient portal. Here, let me give you my username and password so that you can see what my primary care physician sees.”
For Yvonne Wright, the portal system isn’t perfect. Doctors need to make sure what they write is understandable to the patients, she said, or perhaps delay posting critical results until they can see the patient in person to explain what they mean, “because what if it’s something really, really bad?”
But overall, having medical records at her fingertips has helped both her mother and her family deal with her illness, Wright said.
“I think when you’re in control of your own health, it helps you feel better.”
Source CBC News
A call to mandate patient access to personal primary care medical records across Canada, Gorfinkel I, Lexchin J. CMAJ. 2018 Jul 23;190(29):E869-E870. doi: 10.1503/cmaj.180522.
We need to mandate drug cost transparency on electronic medical records, Gorfinkel I, Lexchin J. CMAJ. 2017 Dec 18;189(50):E1541-E1542. doi: 10.1503/cmaj.171070.
Use and the Users of a Patient Portal: Cross-Sectional Study, Hoogenbosch B, Postma J, de Man-van Ginkel JM, Tiemessen NA, van Delden JJ, van Os-Medendorp H. J Med Internet Res 2018;20(9):e262. DOI: 10.2196/jmir.9418
Patient preferences in controlling access to their electronic health records: a prospective cohort study in primary care, Schwartz PH, Caine K, Alpert SA, Meslin EM, Carroll AE, Tierney WM. J Gen Intern Med. 2015 Jan;30 Suppl 1:S25-30. doi: 10.1007/s11606-014-3054-z.
Reasons and Barriers for Using a Patient Portal: Survey Among Patients With Diabetes Mellitus, Maaike CM Ronda MD, Lioe-Ting Dijkhorst-Oei MD PhD, and Guy EHM Rutten MD PhD. J Med Internet Res. 2014 Nov; 16(11): e263. Published online 2014 Nov 25. doi: 10.2196/jmir.3457
Defining and Evaluating Patient-Empowered Approaches to Improving Record Matching, Robert S. Rudin, Richard Hillestad, M. Susan Ridgely, Nabeel Shariq Qureshi, John S. Davis II, Shira H. Fischer. Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation. RR-2275-PCT. DOI: 10.7249/RR2275. PDF
A national electronic health record for primary care, Persaud N. CMAJ. 2019 Jan 14;191(2):E28-E29. doi: 10.1503/cmaj.181647. No abstract available. Full text
A national electronic health record for all Canadians Dr. Brian’s Blog – White Coat, Black Art – CBC Radio
Richard Smith: Ten years of working towards patients controlling their own health records BMJ Opinion
Patient portals showing mixed results Medical Economics
Doctors offered cash bonuses to speed up switch to electronic medical records CBC News
Quebec patients will soon have access to medical records online CBC News
Alberta to launch portal so patients can track health data online CBC News
University Health Network investigating electronic record error CBC News
MyChart: One Toronto hospital’s e-health triumph The Globe and Mail
Seniors slow to embrace online access to doctors Medical Xpress
Poll: Half of older adults don’t use health provider’s secure patient communication site Medical Xpress