Wide variations in car seat breathing assessment conducted on premature newborns

A new study from the University of Maryland School of Medicine (UMSOM) has found wide variations throughout the United States in the way hospitals ensure that premature or low birth weight infants can breathe safely in a car seat before discharging them.

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, NHTSA. Eli Meir Kaplan for Home Front Communications

Bill Seiler, University of Maryland Medical System August 24, 2020

The study, published this month in the journal Pediatrics, found that the same infant who passes a screening in one hospital’s newborn nursery (NBN) may fail in similar facilities at another hospital’s nursery. The authors concluded that “further guidance on screening practices and failure criteria is needed to inform future practice and policy” in order to better protect these vulnerable newborns.

“Proper placement of an infant in their car seat can be a challenge, but it’s important to get it right. Research has shown that 63 percent of infant sleep-related deaths that occur in sitting devices are in car seats,” said the study lead author, Natalie L. Davis, MD, MMSc, Associate Professor of Pediatrics at UMSOM and a Neonatologist at the University of Maryland Children’s Hospital.

The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) recommends a car seat tolerance screen (CSTS) for all premature newborns in the U.S. in order to identify any heart or breathing risks that could make use of a car seat unsafe in these babies whose lungs are not fully developed.

“The infants are placed in a car seat with a breathing and heart rate monitor for an hour-and-a-half to two hours to see if they are breathing effectively,” Dr. Davis said. “The problem is that the AAP recommendations do not have specific guidelines on what to test for and how to test, and do not provide much guidance on what doctors should do if infants fail these tests,” said Dr. Davis.

Hospitalized newborns are placed flat on their backs as part of national “Back-to-Sleep” measures to prevent sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS). “In the hospital, we use monitors on at-risk premature babies, and we do not send them home until they have established normal vital signs in their crib,” said Dr. Davis. When at-risk infants are placed in a car seat for the ride home from the hospital, however, the semi-upright sitting position can pose breathing obstacles that may not be obvious in the flat-back position.

To gain a snapshot of CSTS practices today, the researchers conducted a survey across 35 states using a network of hospitals that participate in an outcomes research network. Of the 84 newborn nurseries surveyed, 90.5 percent reported performing a pre-discharge CSTS. Dr. Davis and her colleagues found, however, that newborn nurseries varied in how they selected newborns to be screened and what parameters they used to identify failure on a test. They also had inconsistent practices in how they dealt with a screening failure in terms of recommendations for parents to use special infant car beds instead of car seats and in making referrals to specialists for follow-up monitoring.

Most NBNs surveyed said they did repeat a CSTS after an initial failure, but the timing ranged from an immediate retest, to a minimum seven-day observation before retesting.

In a previous study published earlier this year in the journal Academic Pediatrics, Dr. Davis and her colleagues also found similar inconsistencies in the use of CSTS among infants discharged from neonatal intensive care units in hospitals throughout the country.

Dr. Davis said the findings from both studies highlight the need for more specific recommendations from the AAP to define failure criteria on these tests and recommended steps for follow-up if an infant fails. While she acknowledged that limited data have made it difficult for the AAP to establish evidence-based guidelines, having nationally consistent recommendations could help improve the collection of data and lead to refinement of the advice if needed.

“If we are all doing something similar,” she said, “then we can consistently see if we are actually catching the babies who are at risk and take the appropriate steps we need to modify from there.”

Two areas that can be improved immediately:

  1. Parents and caregivers can be better educated on the proper placement and fit of an infant in the car seat through the use of child passenger safety technicians at the hospital.
  2. Newborn nurseries should arrange for appropriate post-discharge follow-up, particularly if an infant is sent home in a car bed. Parents will need to know when it is safe to transition their baby to an upright infant car seat.

“This research clearly establishes a need for national standards to ensure that hospitals are providing consistent care to neonates,” said E. Albert Reece MD PhD MBA, a specialist in maternal-fetal medicine, who is Executive Vice President for Medical Affairs, UM Baltimore, and the John Z. and Akiko K. Bowers Distinguished Professor and Dean, University of Maryland School of Medicine. “It also points to the need for better data to help inform our medical societies when they make these public health recommendations.”

Source University of Maryland Medical System via Science Daily


Variation in Car Seat Tolerance Screen Performance in Newborn Nurseries, Davis NL, Hoffman BD, Eichenwald EC. Pediatrics, 2020 Aug;146(2):e20193593. doi: 10.1542/peds.2019-3593. Epub 2020 Jul 8.

A National Survey of Car Seat Tolerance Screening Protocols in Neonatal Intensive Care Units, Davis NL, Cheo S. Acad Pediatr. 2020 Feb 7:S1876-2859(20)30058-9. doi: 10.1016/j.acap.2020.02.004. Epub ahead of print.

  Further reading

Car Seat Tolerance Screening for Late-Preterm Infants, Magnarelli A, Shah Solanki N, Davis NL. Pediatrics. 2020 Jan;145(1):e20191703. doi: 10.1542/peds.2019-1703.

To Test or Not to Test: A Retrospective Review of Infant Car Seat Tolerance Screening at a Single Institution, Kelsi Chan, Benjamin Hoffman, Kathleen Carlson, Brianna Ennis and Tess Gilbert. Pediatrics August 2019, 144 (2 MeetingAbstract) 87; DOI: https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.144.2_MeetingAbstract.87

Post-discharge outcomes of failed car seat tolerance screens: A case-control and follow-up study, Sharma P, Davis NL. J Neonatal Perinatal Med. 2018;11(3):249-255. doi: 10.3233/NPM-1785.

Predictors of Persistent Infant Car Seat Challenge Failure, Mandell L, Rhein LM, Feldman HA, Bergling E, Porter C, DeGrazia M. Adv Neonatal Care. 2017 Dec;17(6):499-508. doi: 10.1097/ANC.0000000000000432. Full text

Going home: Facilitating discharge of the preterm infant, Jefferies AL; Canadian Paediatric Society, Fetus and Newborn Committee. Paediatr Child Health. 2014 Jan;19(1):31-42. Full text

Safe Transportation of Preterm and Low Birth Weight Infants at Hospital Discharge, Marilyn J. Bull, William A. Engle and The Committee on Injury, Violence, and Poison Prevention and the Committee on Fetus and Newborn. Pediatrics May 2009, 123 (5) 1424-1429; DOI: https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2009-0559

Assessment of babies for car seat safety before hospital discharge, Paediatr Child Health. 2000 Jan;5(1):53-63. doi: 10.1093/pch/5.1.53. Full text

Also see
Handle with care: Car seats and newborns Science Daily
Majority of parents with newborns misused car safety seats Healio

Mobility Menu

follow us in feedly

Call 403-240-9100