To coincide with the International Day of Persons with Disabilities on Dec. 3, Statistics Canada released new data about workers with disabilities during the COVID-19 pandemic.
In a news release and corresponding infographic, StatCan reported that workers with and without disabilities had similar rates in receiving CERB (34.9 per cent and 33.3 per cent respectively) and that some workers with disabilities were more likely to receive CERB.
The report, however, overestimates the support provided to Canadians with disabilities. This is because such a small percentage of these individuals were eligible, given their employment status when the pandemic hit.
It casually notes that people with disabilities are less likely to be employed and that workers with disabilities are often segregated into lower paying and precarious jobs that were especially affected by the pandemic.
Although the report does explain the eligibility criteria for receiving CERB, the narrative is somewhat misleading.
Early parallels were drawn with a universal basic income. But CERB was, in the end, a means-tested program — its income and work-related eligibility criteria excluded many who were not employed and did not receive a certain amount of employment income in the prior year. A large number of these individuals are Canadians with disabilities.
|Canadians with disabilities hit hardest|
According to the Canadian Survey on Disability, 59 per cent of working age adults with disabilities were employed in 2017. This is far less than the 80 per cent of working age adults without disabilities.
Employment rates decreased with the severity of disability — only 31 per cent of people with severe disabilities are employed. That means low employment rates, coupled with limited government support, lead to increased poverty and insecurity among people with disabilities. These extant conditions made them vulnerable to adverse events like the pandemic.
Our own research further demonstrates these struggles. We conducted a national survey of Canadians with disabilities and chronic health conditions in June 2020. At that time, only about 22 per cent of our sample had applied for CERB. This was about eight per cent lower than non-disabled workers.
About two-thirds of our sample indicated they had not applied for CERB and had no intention to. Importantly, because half the sample was not working at the time the pandemic hit, these individuals were ineligible for CERB. This left them with few supports to help navigate the financial hardships that COVID-19 exacerbated.
The federal government response when it came to disabled people was a onetime $600 enhanced goods and services tax (GST) payment, given only to those who were registered for a disability tax credit. For most individuals we surveyed and interviewed, this simply wasn’t enough.
Later, the government expanded this program to include an additional 1.7 million Canadians with disabilities who already received either a Canada Pension Plan disability benefit or disability support through Veterans Affairs Canada. Again, this missed many people who received neither. In our sample, only 11 per cent of respondents reported receiving a disability tax credit.
|CERB helped, but was not enough|
No doubt, those who could benefit from CERB felt more financially secure during the pandemic. For some, that’s all the income they had. For others, it supplemented other reduced sources of income.
As one of our respondents noted:
“With CERB I am earning about as much as I would have if I was working full time, if the pandemic hadn’t occurred… I was already in support of universal basic income, but I feel like it’s even more important now.”
People who received CERB also rated government response more highly. Of course, not everyone who relied exclusively on CERB believed they would make it through the pandemic. Many had no idea when and if they’d return to their jobs. Those living in larger cities with expensive housing markets were concerned about losing their homes. Many were trying to manage as their costs of living increased.
On the flip side, many disabled Canadians who could not benefit from CERB were left in a very precarious situation. As one of our respondents who only received limited provincial disability benefits explained: “I live each day on the edge, wondering if I can make ends meet tomorrow and see if I can feed myself type of thing.”
Without any additional financial aid, respondents were left to rely on savings or other family members for support.
|Too many left unsupported|
CERB is an example of a liberal welfare policy that distinguishes between the deserving and undeserving. Benefits were limited to $2,000 per month and taxable. Benefits were only available to people who earned a minimum of $5,000 in the previous year and whose work was directly affected by COVID-19.
In addition, receiving these benefits affected other government supports. Many who received CERB faced unexpected cuts to their guaranteed income supplement (GIS) payments, which are also means-tested.
Such distinctions exacerbate inequalities in times of crisis.A common complaint from disability groups during the pandemic was that disability-support payments were much lower compared to CERB. This was true when comparing CERB to many provincial support benefits.
It’s also why some have filed Charter challenges, alleging disability discrimination in these benefits.
Almost two years into the pandemic, it’s clear that CERB was one of the most important programs for limiting the economic and financial consequences of COVID-19. CERB helped many people, including low-income workers and workers with disabilities.
But it wasn’t enough. Too many people were left unsupported. Like many limited means-tested programs that emphasize work above all else, CERB left out the most vulnerable in our society.
|David Pettinicchio, Associate Professor, Sociology, University of Toronto|
|Michelle Maroto, Associate Professor of Sociology, University of Alberta|
|David Pettinicchio receives funding from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada.|
|Michelle Maroto receives funding from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council (SSHRC).|
Source The Conversation
|Using data from the 2017 Canadian Survey on Disability (CSD) and the 2020 Canada Emergency Response Benefit (CERB) program, this infographic provides a profile of Canadian workers with disabilities who received CERB payments during the period from March 15 to September 26, 2020. The focus of the analysis is on workers who had employment or self-employment income of at least $5,000 in 2019.|
|Workers with disabilities receiving payments from the Canada Emergency Response Benefit program, 2020, Joly, Sonia; Kevins, Christina. Issue Number: 2021083. Stats in brief: 11-627-M2021083. Statistics Canada—Infographics. December 1, 2021|
A demographic, employment and income profile of Canadians with disabilities aged 15 years and over, 2017, Stuart Morris, Gail Fawcett, Laurent Brisebois, Jeffrey Hughes. Canadian Survey on Disability Reports. Journals and periodicals: 89-654-X. Statistics Canada. November 28, 2018. PDF
Perceptions of Canadian Federal Policy Responses to COVID-19 among People with Disabilities and Chronic Health Conditions, David Pettinicchio, Michelle Maroto, and Martin Lukk. Canadian Public Policy 2021 47:2, 231-251. https://doi.org/10.3138/cpp.2021-012. PDF
Working Differently or Not at All: COVID-19’s Effects on Employment among People with Disabilities and Chronic Health Conditions, Maroto, Michelle Lee, David Pettinicchio, and Martin Lukk. Sociological Perspectives 64, no. 5 (October 2021): 876–97. https://doi.org/10.1177/07311214211012018. PDF
CERB was luxurious compared to provincial social assistance The Conversation
Canadians with disabilities face an uncertain financial future The Conversation
The high cost of living in a disabling world – podcast The Guardian